Hiroshima 75 Years Ago Today

Forums:

https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/04/world/gallery/hiroshima-nagasaki-atomic-b...

Today marks the anniversary of the Atomic bomb detonation in Hiroshima.  Considered by some a necessary evil to bring a quick end to the war and prevent greater casualties and destruction, and by others a war crime.  The people of Hiroshima (and Nagasaki four days later) paid a terrible sacrifice that day.  
 

 

 

There is a Buddhist church in my neighborhood. 

 The statue in front of the building is of Shinran Shonin, the founder of the Jodo-Shinsu school of Buddhism;

it was originally located in Hiroshima and survived the atomic bombing.  

It serves as a stark reminder of what humanity is now capable of & not in a good way. 

B991EE15-5586-4F52-A211-A93A86D4AEB7.jpeg

It's always struck me as odd that the Japanese are so obsessed with Western Pop Culture.  Elvis, The Beatles, The Ventures, Soul Music, Jazz.  We nuked their country.
 

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oI64M_L6Uik

Don't Worry Kyoko (Mummy's Only Looking for Her Hand in the Snow)

Yoko Ono with John Lennon, Eric Clapton, Klaus Voorman and Alan White

Live Peace In Toronto, 1969

Yamaguchi, a resident of Nagasaki, was in Hiroshima on business for his employer Mitsubishi Heavy Industries when the city was bombed at 8:15 am, on August 6, 1945. He returned to Nagasaki the following day and, despite his wounds, he returned to work on August 9, the day of the second atomic bombing. That morning, whilst he was being berated by his supervisor as "crazy" after describing how one bomb had destroyed the city, the Nagasaki bomb detonated.[3] In 1957, he was recognized as a hibakusha (explosion-affected person) of the Nagasaki bombing, but it was not until March 24, 2009, that the government of Japan officially recognized his presence in Hiroshima three days earlier. He died of stomach cancer on January 4, 2010, at the age of 93.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsutomu_Yamaguchi

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fpKQOvlDr-s

Grateful Dead-"Morning Dew"

10/18/74

Winterland

Oak ridge Tennessee connection

>>>>Oak ridge Tennessee connection

My great uncle worked on the project at Oak Ridge designing the electrical system for the bomb.  He was with Oppenheimer in New Mexico the night before they tested it and he purportedly told him "I pray that it will not work, but know that it will."

I don't understand why the US didn't just drop the bomb on some remote mountainside or island off the coast just to demonstrate its destructive power without having to level entire cities.   But I guess the US was already in a frenzy destroying Japanese cities with conventional weapons (like the Tokyo firebombings) and probably felt that a couple more wouldn't matter much in the grand scheme of things.

I read the whole Wikipedia article about the Hiroshima bombing a couple of nights ago.  The reasons stated were that:

1) it was untested technology.  The Halo Test had been done from a fixed location in the desert.  This was the first time they were dropping an atomic weapon from a plane.  They were worried that if there was a malfunction, the Japanese wouldn't believe that the weapon was as destructive as being claimed, and would continue the war.

2) they only had the two bombs they used on Hiroshima and Nagasaki ready.  The next one would not be ready until the end of August.  

 

 

My dad was a young chemistry professor that became a nuclear physicist during WWII. Went to Lawrence Livermore lab, and was recruited  and  also worked on the Manhattan project developing uranium and he relocated to Oak Ridge Tennessee where my brother was born, I was born in Richland Washington  ...in his later years 80- 95 years of age he was an energy economist 

 

EMK died at over 101 and was an amazing man. Loved art, gardening, music and orchids, And his politically liberal and active family

I don't understand why the US didn't just drop the bomb on some remote mountainside or island off the coast just to demonstrate its destructive power without having to level entire cities.   But I guess the US was already in a frenzy destroying Japanese cities with conventional weapons (like the Tokyo firebombings) and probably felt that a couple more wouldn't matter much in the grand scheme of things.<<<<

I think at that point in the war, all sides had already "doubled down" 1000x over ... the Japanese were also executing American POW's and prepared to take things to the bitter end. 

But yeah, one would think a simple demonstration would've been sufficient for "rational" people to get the message.

Here is an interesting take on that question of why they used the bomb twice.

According to his close examination of the evidence, Japan was not poised to surrender before Hiroshima, as the revisionists argued, nor was it ready to give in immediately after the atomic bomb, as traditionalists have always seen it.…Americans, then and today, have tended to assume that Japan’s leaders were simply blinded by their own fanaticism, forcing a catastrophic showdown for no reason other than their refusal to acknowledge defeat.…But Hasegawa and other historians have shown that Japan’s leaders were in fact quite savvy, well aware of their difficult position, and holding out for strategic reasons.

Their concern was not so much whether to end the conflict, but how to end it while holding onto territory, avoiding war crimes trials, and preserving the imperial system. The Japanese could still inflict heavy casualties on any invader, and they hoped to convince the Soviet Union, still neutral in the Asian theater, to mediate a settlement with the Americans. Stalin, they calculated, might negotiate more favorable terms in exchange for territory in Asia. It was a long shot, but it made strategic sense.

More here

https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2020/08/why-did-world-war-ii-end-2/