Brian Wilson in Court Conservatorship

Forums:

We were so lucky to enjoy his talents. Glad I went to that Pet Sounds tour a few years ago. 

LOS ANGELES — A judge found Thursday that Beach Boys founder and music luminary Brian Wilson should be in a court conservatorship to manage his personal and medical decisions because of what his doctor calls a "major neurocognitive disorder."

At a hearing, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Gus T. May approved the petition filed by the family and inner circle of 81-year-old Wilson after the death in January of his wife, Melinda Ledbetter Wilson, who handled most of his tasks and affairs.

"I find from clear and convincing evidence that a conservatorship of the person is necessary," May said at the brief hearing. The judge said that evidence shows that Wilson consents to the arrangement and lacks the capacity to make health care decisions.

May appointed two longtime Wilson representatives, publicist Jean Sievers and manager LeeAnn Hard, as his conservators.

There were no significant objections raised.

Two of Wilson's seven children, Carnie Wilson and Wendy Wilson from the singing group Wilson Phillips, asked through their attorney that all the children be added to a group text chain about their father, and that all be consulted on medical decisions. The judge granted the stipulations.

The two daughters had asked for a delay in the process at an April 30 hearing while issues were worked out, but it was clear at the hearing that consensus had been reached.

A doctor's declaration filed with the petition in February said Wilson has a "major neurocognitive disorder," is taking medication for dementia, and "is unable to properly provide for his own personal needs for physical health, food, clothing, or shelter."

'Mostly difficult to understand'

Sievers and Hard have had a close relationship with Wilson and his wife for many years. In a report, Robert Frank Cipriano, an attorney appointed by the court to represent Wilson's interests, said Wilson acknowledged the need for the conservatorship, and said he trusts the judgment of the two women.

Cipriano's report to the court said he visited Wilson at his "impeccably well-maintained residence in Beverly Hills," where he lives with two daughters and a long-term live-in caregiver.

Wilson can move around with help from a walker and the caregiver, Cipriano said, and he has a good sense of who he is, where he is, and when it is, but could not name his children beyond the two that live with him.

He said Wilson was "mostly difficult to understand and gave very short responses to questions and comments."

Cipriano said he approved of the conservatorship, mostly because of Wilson's general consent.

'No extreme changes'

Wilson credited Ledbetter with stabilizing his famously troubled life after they met in the mid-1980s and married in 1995.

Wilson, his seven children, his caregiver, and his doctors consulted before the petition was filed, according to a family statement at the time. It said the decision was to ensure "there will be no extreme changes" and that "Brian will be able to enjoy all of his family and friends and continue to work on current projects."

Judges in California can appoint a conservator for a person, their finances — referred to as the estate — or both, as was the case with Britney Spears. Spears' case brought attention — much of it negative — to conservatorships, known in some states as guardianships, and prompted legislative changes. Wilson's case is closer to the typical traditional use of a conservatorship, which very often is installed for an older person in irreversible mental decline.

The Wilson petition did not seek a conservator of the estate because his assets are in a trust, with Hard as a trustee.

Deeply revered and acclaimed as a co-founder, producer, arranger and chief songwriter of the Beach Boys and a masterful innovator of vocal harmony, Wilson struggled with mental health and substance abuse issues that upended his career in the 1960s.

He was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 1988 along with his bandmates, including his brothers Carl Wilson and Dennis Wilson and his cousin Mike Love.

So sad.  Didn't know his wife recently passed away.   Happens all too often when an elderly person loses their long time partner/support.  

Brian Wilson is a total hero and legend to me.  I'm also glad I got to see him play many times (Pet Sounds, Smile, Bridge School, etc).

I put him in the same class as:

Dylan

McCartney

NY

This is sad news, but Wilson did have a nice second act after his problems in the 70s-80s. It sounds like the family is on board with the plan too, so he's got some harmony on that front at least.

Happens all too often when an elderly person loses their long time partner/support. 

its a much more significant event for wilson than it would be for most people, melinda is essentially the person who saved brian from dr. landy, and while they didnt pubically acknowledge it, it was very obvious that melinda has essentially been brian's caregiver for decades now, and the only reason he did not need to be put under conservatorship ages ago is because he was married to melinda, who acted in that capacity for brian, who obviously hasnt been able to care for himself or deal with financial/business affairs for decades now.

IME, many of brian's fans have been hoping he would retire from the road and live  out his remaining days at home with melinda, but unfortunately that wasnt to be the case. brian has not been capable of preforming for years. his last couple tours mostly consisted of the vestigies of the brian wilson band, playing brian's songs while he sits motionless at his piano. even when brian tries to sing lead vocals on a song, he usually cant make it past the first verse before his band mates have to cover for him. its really really tough to watch.

ive actually been seeing brian's shows for longer than ive been into the dead. my favorite show of his i was able to see was his "lucky old sun" tour in 2007, and im very thankful to have caught it. i wasnt "on the bus" enough to have caught his 2004 smile tour, which imo is the best tour brian ever did in his whole career including with the beach boys. lucky old sun was a solid consolation prize for me. lucky old sun is one of his best albums, right up there with pet sounds and smile, and is his last work that really attempted to make music in the vein of pet sounds and smile. his albums after lucky old sun were much lower quality, and then that led up to the BB50th shows, which IMO was the beginning of the end for brian, resulting in one of his closest longtime bandmembers, jeff foskett, leaving brian's band in favor of mike love's beach boys. it was all downhill from there. getting to hear brian sing "i just wasnt made for these times" was a bucket list experience, but the rest of those shows were pretty bad compared to the stuff brian had been doing with his solo band up until that point.

the "lucky old sun" show  i caught in oakland in 2007 is one of my most unforgettable concert experiences. the first set was all crowd pleasing beach boys material, and brian really struggled to get thru it, often just sitting there looking confused while his band played the songs for him, even at one point audibly asking the band to slow down cause he couldnt keep up, into the mic that went out to the audience. this was my first experience with brian, and i really wasnt prepared for how obviously mentally ill he would appear onstage. i was really really uncomfortable, and the fact that everyone around me was just blindly singing along to corny old beach boys songs made it even more uncomfortable.

then for his second set, he played the "lucky old sun" album from start to finish, and it was clear from the very first note that something had changed very dramatically. his singing was amazing, he hit every line, every note, he was confident, smiling, and fully engaged. once he was able to sing the songs he was actually exited about, that were written for his voice today, it was like he turned into a different person. i have never in my life felt the vibe of a concert, or any event, shift on a dime like that. it was like a butterfly emerging from his cocoon, and to this day remains one of the best shows ive ever seen.

obviously brian's band is a very different beast than the kinds of bands we usually discuss, i doubt they have much capacity for improvisation and the like, but as far as playing composed music, the lineup for the brian wilson band during the BWPS glory days from the early 2000s up until the BB50th shows was one of the best live bands in rock music.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mptoIXjvE6w

 

also, for deadheads its worth keeping in mind the direct line of influence here - its pretty well known that the dead decided to fully embrace electric rock over jugband music due to influence from the beatles sgt peppers lonely hearts club band, which was a direct response to the beach boys pet sounds. the grateful dead may well not have been the grateful dead we know and love today were it not for brian's groundbreaking work on pet sounds.

Brian with Mike, Al, and Bruce, along with Blondie Chaplin and David Marks May 21, 2024 at the premiere of the new disney+ BB's documentary

pqns8son1y1d1.png

 

Brian talking with his first wife, Marylin Wilson-Rutherford at the premiere. AFAIK though there isnt significant bad blood, these two rarely communicate and are almost never seen in public together

brianmarylin.jpeg

 

Brian watching himself in the new doc, photo taken by his daughter Carnie

brian2x.jpeg

 

My son and I saw this last night for free at the Sony Metreon IMAX in downtown SF.  Fantastic!

The world will always be a better place because I got to share it at the same time as Brian Wilson, and still do, for now.

Brian with Mike, Al, and Bruce, along with Blondie Chaplin and David Marks May 21, 2024 at the premiere of the new disney+ BB's documentary<<<

Too bad Mike didn't listen to Brian re: Don Jr. Trophy hunting concert ...

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/brian-wilson-beach-boys-mi...

Sad to hear, regardless.

mike love is a well known trumper, because of course he is. one of the truest and most central villain characters in rock and roll history imo. few rock stars have an unbroken streak of being a lame asshole for as long as mike love. he is the human personification of materialism and mediocrity in pop/rock music. a true innovator in the process of formulizing and exploiting a band or type of music for pure profit and fame.

he even has a little commentary he does show after show, before his band plays "california girls", about how he might get in trouble for singing that song because its "gender specific". i was happy to see the remaining beach boys together for the 50th as a fan, although the show wasnt the best, there were some high points, it was great getting to hear brian sing "i just wasnt made for these times" and to hear al do "help me rhonda", but it pains me to have given money to mike and actually gone to see him live. 

Lived next door to Brian in the late 80s and early 90s.  Landy eventually moved in and shit was crazy.  Painted the house neon purple and built a watchtower so he could see over the neighborhood.   Eventually after the legal issues, they split and sold the place.  One day, a lawyer dropped three 90 minutes Maxell cassettes in our mailbox by accident with hours of interviews with Landy and Wilson.  Still have em.  

Dammit! That's where those ended up! 

 it pains me to have given money to mike and actually gone to see him live<<

I understand wanting to  see the band together as a whole, but yeah, Mike Love is on my "list" (not a good one), and I always take every opportunity to post that Rolling Stone article on any venue page / social media post.

usually im not really the type to see shows for reasons like "wanting to see the band together again", i usually heavily prioritize music and will actively miss out on seeing musical idols of mine if i think the show will be low quality.

but brian, al, mike and bruce sang on fucking pet sounds dude. i had to go

>>>its pretty well known that the dead decided to fully embrace electric rock over jugband music due to influence from the beatles sgt peppers lonely hearts club band<<<

That may be well known, but it's not accurate. The Grateful Dead were an electric rock band at least two years prior to sgt peppers being released. It was Rolling Stones records they used as a model for how they wanted to sound.

This conservancy sounds like a good thing. Brian Wilson is 81, has been mentally ill for most of his life and probably should have died decades ago. It's amazing that he had the huge late career resurgence and has made it this far, seemingly thanks mostly to his wife, but at this point with his wife gone he needs help, so it's good that this time the right people will be taking care of him.

(Allow me to indulge in a couple of my Brian Wilson stories)......

I learned to love Brian Wilson when he performed at the 1999 Bridge School Benefit at Shoreline. I had always thought of The Beach Boys as fluffy background music, mostly taking their music for granted and never really thinking of them as a legitimate band.

My attitude wasn't helped when they performed at a benefit concert in Oakland in 1980 with the Grateful Dead, Jefferson Starship, Santana and others. They were horrible. Mike Love was clearly drunk, stumbling and slurring while rambling about politics, forgetting words and committing what I was taught is the height of amateurism and a mortal sin of live performance, stopping a song and starting it over because he flubbed the words. My attitude after that was always, Beach Boys? County Fair drivel.

That '99 Bridge lineup was stacked, featuring The Who, Tom Waits, Pearl Jam, Green Day, Smashing Pumpkins, Bonny Raitt, Lucinda Williams & Sheryl Crow, so I barely gave Wilson a thought heading into it, thinking he would be just a little empty nostalgia moment between the meat. Boy, was I wrong about that.

At the start Wilson was shaky, his voice was thin and he was sitting at an electric piano that wasn't plugged into anything, but his band was brilliant and it was HIM singing all those classic songs. I wasn't planning on watching the whole set, but hearing that music played live by a top quality band was a revelation to me, the multiple layers of sound, the glorious harmonies, the FUN. By the middle of the second song the entire crowd was on their feet, which was pretty rare at Bridge shows because they were all acoustic performances. I was right there with them, and the energy got to Wilson as well, as he became more & more engaged and animated as his set went on.

During the last song I looked over at the side of the stage, and every performer that night was crowded together, rocking out. At that moment Pete Townsend, Roger Daultry, Tom Waits, Neil Young, Eddie Vedder, the Green Day guys were all just starry-eyed fans, and as 22,000 people roared at the end of his set it hit me that Brian Wilson wasn't just a story from the old days, he was a true legend, and his music was legendary & timelessly great.

That set was not only one of my favorites from any of the 30 years of Bridge Benefit shows I saw, it remains a favorite from ANY of the shows I saw at Shoreline over 36 years, which is about 98% of the shows performed at the Dump during that time.

I then had the opportunity to have some personal interaction with Wilson when he performed again at the Bridge Benefit in 2006. At the beginning of every Bridge show Neil would start the show by playing a couple of solo songs. I always tried to catch those and was hustling through the backstage area as a short cut to the bowl. I was walking right past Wilson & his wife as they were telling Neil's tour manager that Brian wanted to go out into the house to see Neil's songs. Neil's manager was telling him that wasn't a good idea but Brian just walked away and out into the theater with his wife. Neil's guy knew me and grabbed me, telling me to stay with them, make sure they were seated somewhere and to make sure no one bothered him, clearly worried about Wilson's "stability".

I found them just standing in an isle creating a bit of a buzz, so I escorted them to some seats I knew were empty. I asked him how he felt about people approaching him and if he wanted me to keep folks away. He smiled at me and told me not to worry about it, that he was fine and liked interacting with his fans. He then asked me my name and what I did at the venue, and then insisted that I sit down with them and enjoy Neil's songs, which was fine with me.

For the next fifteen minutes multiple people came up to him, asking for autographs, shaking his hand, telling him what his music had meant to them. He was pleasant and affable with everyone, while also being respectful that Neil was performing. In other words, he was completely lucid, alert & aware, with a sly sense of humor.

But then, about three hours later I was in the backstage catering line when Wilson barged in, shoved his way to the front of the line and started yelling, "MASHED POTATOES!!! MASHED POTATOES!!! I WANT MASHED POTATOES!!!"

His eyes were looking two different directions, his face was blank, he was completely out of it. His wife came in and gently lead him out of the room while Wilson held his plate muttering, "mashed potatoes".

The message that came to me was...... Medication. It can be a good thing.

Anyway,

LONG LIVE BRIAN WILSON!

We might have had Smile in 1967 if it weren't for Mike Love.

Think for a minute about that alternate universe, where Brian saw his vision through and Sgt Pepper's got one-upped.

>> '99 Bridge lineup was stacked

I was at that one and had completely forgotten that moment

thanks for that

i don't like the beach boys or the beatles...

i know.

Lance - you write the best stories.  Thank you for sharing that.  Freaking awesome thinking about Daltry, Townsend and Tom Waits starry eyed.

Love those stories

Got mashed potatoes.

Ain't got no t-bone.